Polar vs LemonSqueezy vs Paddle: merchant of record in 2026
What a merchant of record does, what each of the three charges, and which fits an independent software seller.
On this page
A merchant of record is the company that legally sells your product to the customer, so it also collects the sales tax and VAT and deals with chargebacks. Polar, LemonSqueezy and Paddle all charge a percentage plus a fixed fee per sale. On small $20 sales, the fixed fee is a large part of the cost.
What a merchant of record does
A normal payment processor moves money. You are the seller, so you owe sales tax in the places where you have to collect it, and you handle disputes yourself.
A merchant of record (MoR) changes who the seller is. The customer buys from the MoR, the MoR collects and files the tax, and you receive a payout after fees. Paddle's pricing page lists "global tax and regulatory compliance" and "fraud protection, chargebacks, and buyer support" as part of its single fee. LemonSqueezy's pricing page says "we take on the liability of tax collection and calculation."
That is the reason to pay a MoR. You trade a bigger fee per sale for not registering for tax in every place your customers live. It suits an independent developer selling a software licence, a template, a course or a subscription to buyers in many countries.
What each one charges
All three publish a per-sale price. Here is what the pages said when I checked them.
Polar. Polar's fee page lists five rows of base fees: Starter at 5% plus $0.50, Pro at 3.8% plus $0.40, Growth at 3.6% plus $0.35, Scale at 3.4% plus $0.30, and a legacy Early Member rate of 4% plus $0.40. International cards add 1.5% for non-US cards. A dispute costs $15 whatever the outcome. Payouts go through Stripe, which charges $2 a month for active payouts plus 0.25% plus $0.25 per payout, and cross-border conversion costs 0.25% in the EU and 1% elsewhere. Polar raised a $10 million seed round led by Accel, according to its own announcement.
LemonSqueezy. Its pricing page lists 5% plus $0.50 per transaction with no monthly charge for ecommerce features. It acts as the merchant of record. It also notes that transactions outside the US may carry small extra fees, and that volume pricing means contacting sales. Stripe bought the company in July 2024, which TechCrunch reported with deal terms undisclosed. The pricing page now promotes a "2026 Update: Lemon Squeezy + Stripe Managed Payments" without explaining how that changes fees, so read the current page before you commit.
Paddle. Paddle's pricing page lists pay-as-you-go at 5% plus $0.50 per checkout transaction, with no monthly, migration or hidden fees. Custom pricing exists for high-volume or complex needs, and products under $10 need a conversation with Paddle for bespoke pricing.
The headline is the same for the entry tiers: 5% plus 50 cents. The differences are in the tiers, the extras and what you are allowed to sell.
A worked example: $150,000 a year
Suppose you sell a $20 monthly subscription and collect $150,000 in a year. That is 7,500 charges.
At 5% plus $0.50, the fee is $7,500 plus $3,750, or $11,250. The percentage looks like 5%, but the real rate is 7.5%, because the fixed fee on a $20 sale is another 2.5%.
At Polar's lower rows, the same year costs:
- Pro, 3.8% plus $0.40: $5,700 plus $3,000, or $8,700.
- Growth, 3.6% plus $0.35: $5,400 plus $2,625, or $8,025.
- Scale, 3.4% plus $0.30: $5,100 plus $2,250, or $7,350.
Add 1.5% on any non-US cards, the payout charges and $15 per dispute. If a fifth of your revenue comes from non-US cards, that is another $450 on this example. Which row you qualify for depends on Polar's own terms, so read the page for the conditions.
Two lessons. First, the fixed fee matters more than the percentage on cheap products. A $5 product at 5% plus $0.50 loses 15% to fees. Second, the cheapest row is not always available to you. Compare the row you can actually get.
Which one fits which seller
Fees are close enough that product fit decides.
Polar presents itself as a developer-focused platform. If you sell software with benefits such as licence keys or access to a private repository, read its docs against your product.
LemonSqueezy suits a seller who already uses Stripe and wants the MoR layer under the same company. Since the acquisition it sits closer to Stripe's own products, and the fee page now points to Stripe Managed Payments. Ask whether your use case runs on the old checkout or the new one.
Paddle has the longest track record of the three in selling software subscriptions, and its pricing page describes custom plans for high-volume sellers. If you expect volume, ask for a quote and compare it with the published rows above.
Do not choose only by price. Check how each handles refunds, how fast payouts arrive in your country, what they refuse to sell, and how you export the customer and tax data you will need for your own books. Tax treatment depends on your country, so check it with your accountant.
When you do not need a merchant of record
A MoR is a good fit for digital products sold to many buyers. It is a poor fit for work you do for a client you know.
If you invoice a client for a project, you are the seller, and they are paying you for your work. A MoR would take 5% or more of that invoice, and it puts a third party between you and the client relationship. Many service businesses are better off invoicing directly, with the tax details on the invoice, and getting paid through their own gateway. Our post on who holds your money when a client pays online explains the difference, and Stripe vs PayPal vs regional gateways compares the gateway fees you would pay instead.
A rough test: if your customer is a business that will sign a contract and receive an invoice, you probably do not need a MoR. If your customer is a stranger on the internet buying a $20 download, you probably do.
How Delivvo fits next to a merchant of record
Delivvo is not a merchant of record and does not try to be one. It handles the other kind of selling: the client work where you quote, sign a contract, take a deposit and invoice. If you sell a product through Polar, LemonSqueezy or Paddle and also take on client projects, the two do not conflict.
For the client side, the flow is:
- An inquiry form captures the request and puts it on the lead board.
- You send a quote from packages and add-ons.
- The client signs the contract and pays the deposit from the same link.
- You invoice with a sequential number and the tax details your country requires, including reverse charge where it applies. Check the wording with your accountant.
- The client pays through your own gateway. You are the seller, the money goes to you, and Delivvo takes 0%.
That last point is the concrete difference. A MoR takes its percentage because it is the seller. Delivvo takes nothing from the payment because you are. On a $10,000 project, the 5% a MoR would charge is $500, and with Delivvo the only fee is your gateway's.
Every invoice and receipt also carries a verification code, so a client's finance team can check it without asking you for a copy. The client opens the portal with a one-time code instead of a password. If you hand a project to a teammate, the people and roles in Delivvo decide who sees the invoices and who only sees the tasks. See the invoices and tax page and the payments page. For retainers and metered work, our post on usage-based pricing vs retainers covers how to bill.
For the wider picture, see Delivvo for teams and the CRM for service businesses.
FAQ
What is a merchant of record?
It is the company that is legally the seller of a product. It collects the tax, handles refunds and chargebacks, and pays you what is left after its fee.
Is Polar cheaper than LemonSqueezy and Paddle?
On the published pages, Polar's lower rows (3.8%, 3.6% and 3.4%) are below the 5% plus $0.50 entry rate that LemonSqueezy and Paddle list. Which Polar row applies depends on its terms, so check before you assume.
Did Stripe buy LemonSqueezy?
Yes. TechCrunch reported the acquisition on 26 July 2024. LemonSqueezy's pricing page now mentions Stripe Managed Payments, so read it for what that means for fees.
Do I need a merchant of record to sell to clients?
Usually not. A project invoice from you to a business client is a normal sale where you are the seller. A MoR is built for selling digital products to many buyers who do not sign contracts.
Does a merchant of record handle every tax issue?
It handles the collection and filing it takes on for each sale. Your own income tax and your local registration rules still apply, so check your position with an accountant.
Delivvo runs the whole client cycle for service businesses, from the first inquiry to the quote, contract, deposit, invoice and delivery, so client projects get paid without a middleman taking a percentage. Clients pay you directly through your own gateway, and Delivvo takes 0%. Start free